The next day, after what court documents refer to as a 'robbery and triple homicide,' Gilbreath was questioned about the crimes. Officers then asked her if she knew where Gardipee was, and she 'became very evasive and said she had not seen him since Friday December 13.' She denied having any contact with Gardipee recently. She agreed to allow them to look for Gardipee in the residence, but he was not there. Officers stopped the vehicle, and Gilbreath was inside. The officers saw two women drive away from the residence in the vehicle. Gardipee had been in several high-speed chases with officers recently using that vehicle.
The court documents state that on Monday, December 16 (the day before the murders) police officers saw a vehicle that belonged to Gardipee. According to court documents, Gilbreath was known to be in a relationship with Gardipee. Gilbreath has been charged with obstructing justice (felony).